The 4th International Laboratory for the History of Science
Art, Science and Techniques of Drafting in the Renaissance
24 May - 1 June 2001
Florence and Vinci, Italy

Organized by Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza


LUCIA NUTI

Perspective and map-making. Topography, urban views and instruments

The paper is focused on the relationship between chorografic representations and instruments, starting form the first modern town view, Florence " with the chain".
Generally speaking, the use of technical devices to control the metrical consistency of painted space was fully accepted and valued in Northern Europe. On the contrary the assumption that the eye is the only arbiter of the picture was widespread and long-lived in Italian culture. Italian painters like Michelangelo or Vasari usually dismissed mechanical aids because they were thought to interfere with the mental creative process.
The same Vasari, however, is proud of explaining how the compass helped him in drawing a topographical view of Florence.
The value for a total picture, which incorporates the abstract exactness of measurement and overcomes the limitation of the single pictorial language, was a widely recognized feeling among scholars and echoed in many sixteenth century records.
Of course, the terms of this relationship between eye and instrument are changeable and in each case the elements of the game -drawing from life, measuring by instruments, choosing the type of instrument, taking advantage of topographical features, correcting by eye- play a different quantitative and qualitative role. So every view is a world of its own and its system does not automatically applies to all cases. Apart from a few exceptional cases in which the author himself, like Vasari, explains his methods, we have to find tracks of the process of construction inside the picture itself.
In the late fifteenth and in the early sixteenth centuries the kind of surveying instruments that were in use brought about the method of a central reference point.
A transit dial with magnetic compass is responsible for plans like Imola, Portsmouth, but is also at the basis of a much more complex image, even if much more difficult to be discovered, as the representation of Venice, attributed to Jacopo de' Barbari.
A new season for town views started over about the middle of the sixteenth century, when surveying instruments had improved and new methods were developed.
A wide literature flourished on the subject of practical mathematics, such as calculating the positions of distant and inaccessible points. The authors of the booklets present their own instruments, outlining the very great ease and advantage for architects or painters in using them, when they want to depict a building or a town, and not only in plan, but in elevation.
A rich imagery celebrated the instruments used, sometimes beside the portrait of the author, to account for and enhance the techniques and the specialized mathematical skill required to produce pictorial illusions.