The 4th International Laboratory for the History of Science
Art, Science and Techniques of Drafting in the Renaissance
24 May - 1 June 2001
Florence and Vinci, Italy

Organized by Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza


ROBERTO LUNARDI

Iconographical and iconological notes

"Et Jesum - benedictum fructum ventris tui, - nobis post hoc exsilium ostende"

This essay presents the confirmation of the Masaccio Trinity's primary meaning. This work of Dominican art is not a funeral monument, but a triumphal celebration of the eternity of the human life, that is earthly and divine as the nature of Christ, the Trinity's second Person. He is the Only-Begotten of the Father, incarnated by the Holy Ghost and born of the Virgin Mary, as the Credo recites and as this work of art solemnly proclaims.
Painted by Masaccio with refined tecniques and planed by Brunelleschi, the Trinity is the most modern painting produced by the Western culture at that time. Besides representing the main topic of the Dominican preaching, this work is certainly connected to the Council of Florence. In this occasion Roman and Orthodox Churches disputed the Filioque topic: Latins supported the thesis of the descent of the Holy Ghost from the Father and the Son, while Orthodoxes supported Its descent from the only Father.
Since the Council of Constance (1414-1418), a new Council for the reunion of the two Churches had been planed. In Costance, where ended the Western schism, a diplomatic mission from Constantinople and an ambassador from the Florentine Republic, Leonardo di Stagio Dati General of the Dominican Order, were present.
Since January 1418, moreover, the Florentine Republic ordered to prepare a worthy residence for the new Pope, Martin V, inside the Santa Maria Novella cloister: the Pope lived in that residence from February 1418 to September 1419.
From June 1433 to April 1436 also Pope Eugene IV lived in that place and in 1439 the Council of Florence occurred in the Dominican church.
The Masaccio's fresco, located in a preminent position, nearby the pulpit, was the very first image that was visible from the Via degli Avelli's main entrance. Therefore, during the Council the painting played an important role in reconfirming the Faith. According to Dominican preaching, however, this reconfirmation was possible just through the Virgin Mary: the Church is dedicated to Her as well as the magnificent Madonna, painted by Duccio and now exhibited at the Uffizi Museum, but that should be moved back to the church for a complete comprehension of the Masaccio's Trinity.
The Black Friars' prayer in the occasion of their entrance in the Order and of their death is the Salve Regina. The Masaccio's Virgin Mary, with the noble and firm gesture of Her hand showing Her Son and with Her piercing glance casted at bystanders, is the Queen saluting and standing in front of the great mystery of the Faith: Salve Regina.
She is the Queen which repersents us in front of God, defends us as the seat of the divine Law wisdom, hears our prayer: "Eja ergo, advocata nostra - illos tuos misericordes oculos - ad nos converte. - Et Jesum, - benedictum fructum ventris tui,- nobis post hoc exsilium ostende".
She is the Virgin and the Mother, Her Son's doughter, according to Dante, and She looks after us and shows us Her Son, dead on the Cross, but alive in the Father and in the Holy Ghost.
His blood drops on the wood and down on the Galgotha, restoring to life the skeleton that laid on the bier ("IO . FU . GIA' . QUEL . CHE . VOI . SIETE . QUEL . CHI . SON . VOI . ANCOR . SARETE", "I used to be what you are, and you will be what I am", actually this phrase is not a memento mori, but it has to be referred to the God's promise of eternal life). This expectation of resurrection from the death is supported by Christ's resurrection.
The two figures, kneeling between the bier and the triumphal arch, represent not only those one who ordered the painting, but the believers too.
The composition's absolut unity remarks the main topic: dark blue and red alternate, while the Holy Ghost's white dove and the Christ's white girdle draw bystanders' eye on the painting's centre: Christ, which reveals the divinity of the human condition, made in God's own image and likeness, and able to place the Man at the centre of the Universe. Outside: chaos.
The fresco is located in a particular position on the wall, in front of the large door that had been walled up by Vasari, after the Council of Trent (1563), but that used to be the most frequented by the time the fresco had been painted. At the present that door has been re-opened and the fresco appears, once again, in the middle of the field of vision.
Althought a central vision is valid from a close point of view, several architectonical features of the composition are decentralized from the median axis and only a vision from the right rectifys them optically. These two possible points of view document a probable collaboration between Masaccio and Brunelleschi.
The architectonic structure is a real triumphal arch, that embraces and exalts the Trinity.
This fresco is a concise and permanent description of the principles of the Christian Faith, the firm bulwark of the Dominican preaching.